Best of Denver
5 Best Italian Restaurants in Castle Rock
Castle Rock offers some of the best italian restaurants in Douglas County. From neighborhood favorites to hidden gems, locals have strong opinions about where to go.
We analyzed thousands of Google reviews from Douglas County residents to find the spots that consistently deliver. No paid placements. No sponsorships. Just real feedback from real neighbors.
Whether you're a longtime resident or new to the area, these are the italian restaurants Castle Rock locals keep coming back to.
Scileppi's at The Old Stone Church — 4.5 stars with 1.9K+ reviews
Scileppi's at The Old Stone Church — Great quality at $$ prices
Scileppi's at The Old Stone Church — Top-rated by Castle Rock locals
Angie's Restaurant Castle Rock — A neighborhood staple
🍕 Pizza by the Slice: Try the unique and delicious pizza slices, especially during lunch for a quick, affordable meal.
🏛 Historic Ambiance: The old church setting with stained glass windows creates a memorable dining environment not found elsewhere in Castle Rock.
🍸 Bartender Recommendations: The bar team excels at cocktail suggestions like the pistachio martini, enhancing the dining experience.
🌿 Vegetarian-Friendly Options: Clearly labeled vegetarian dishes make ordering easy for plant-based diners.
🍕 Best Happy Hour: Weekday afternoons 3–6 PM offer top value on drinks and appetizers—arrive early to beat the crowd.
🥂 Brunch Highlights: Weekend brunch starts at 9 AM; the Field of Greens Calzone and draft beer make a popular combo.
🪑 Seating Choices Matter: Inside booths offer cozy privacy, while some outside tables near the curb feel less comfortable.
🚗 Parking Tips: Free street parking is available but can be hard to find; plan extra time or consider weekday visits for easier parking.
🍽️ Try the Gluten-Free Dishes: The restaurant's gluten-free pasta options are highly recommended and consistently praised by regulars.
👨👩👧 Kid-Friendly Menu and Atmosphere: Families appreciate the accommodating staff and kid-sized portions, especially pizza and pasta dishes.
🍹 Cocktails Complement Meals: The bar offers great cocktails which enhance the casual dining experience.
🅿️ Parking Can Vary: Plenty of free parking is available but during busy times, street parking can be a bit tricky; planning ahead helps.
🌄 Best Sunset Spot: Time your visit close to sunset for stunning golden-hour light over the plains and distant Denver skyline.
🐂 Bison Viewing Tips: Watch for bison near the main road and the enclosure; maintain a safe distance and never approach.
🥾 Easy Trails for All: The park offers gentle loop and out-and-back paths perfect for families and casual hikers.
🚻 Facilities Available: Utilize the rustic picnic tables and public restrooms located near the shelter for convenient breaks.
🍝 Generous Portions: Expect large servings; taking leftovers home is common and encouraged.
🍻 Great Drink Selection: The beer, wine, and cocktail menus are thoughtfully curated complementing the Italian menu.
🍪 Ask About Desserts: Don't miss homemade sweets like cannolis and Reese's cup cookies—often raved about by locals.
🚗 Parking Ease: Plenty of free parking is available, making visits hassle-free even during busy evenings.
This guide is based entirely on public Google reviews from Douglas County residents. We weighted ratings, review volume, and recency to surface the spots locals genuinely love.
Have a favorite we missed? Reviews change over time, and we update this guide regularly to reflect what the community is saying.
Looking for events? Check out what's happening in Castle Rock this week.
